Katies Kitchen Lancaster, PA

11 Authentic Amish Restaurants in Lancaster PA

Sharing is caring!

11 Authentic Amish Restaurants in Lancaster PA

Everyone knows the Amish always sprinkle a bit of love on their food.

Amish Restaurants in Lancaster PA is perfect for people looking for comfort food and have a large sweet tooth that never gets satisfied! That’s why Amish Restaurants in Lancaster PA is perfect for me.

People fit into 2 categories, they live to eat or they eat to live.

I know it sound odd but I’ve seen it. I’ve been around it. Believe it or not, NOT everyone likes food. I wish that I could say it’s me, that I’m the one that doesn’t like food but I’m definitely a foodie.

Table of Contents

Authentic Amish Restaurants Lancaster, PA

Where to eat Amish Food in Lancaster PA

I like to plan out different places to eat and plan road Trips to restaurants. Like I said, I do enjoy my comfort food and my sweets.

Lancaster County is centrally located and within an hour drive of many cities and towns. When you get the chance to take a road trip through Amish Country, I promise you’ll be able to tell which has Amish style cooking from the outside of the building. You’ll have plenty of restaurants to choose from.

 Philadelphia to Lancaster 71 miles

Baltimore to Lancaster 77 miles

Harrisburg to Lancaster 39 Miles

Allentown to Lancaster 68 miles

Are Amish Restaurants in Lancaster PA open on Sunday’s

One thing important to note: Theses restaurants are closed on Sundays. 6 days a week are for working. Sunday’s are considered a holy day. The Lord’s day, a day for rest and family.

What is the difference between Smorgasbord VS Buffet

Let’s clear up the controversy. Sometimes you’ll see Smorgasbord, other times you see buffet. Are they the same? To make things more complicated the answer is no, they are not the same. Think of it like this a smorgasbord of food is laid out on a buffet. When a restaurant says they have a buffet or a smorgasbord both will mean the same thing. You pay a flat fee for an all you can eat food bar.

Amish Restaurants in Lancaster County PA

It’s true, comfort food does carry a lot of carbohydrates but you will be eating healthy. The meals are made with ingredients that come straight from the local farms in the area so you’ll be getting foods that are fresh, without preservatives [Farm to Table] then made from scratch.


If you make your stop at an Amish diner, I will suggest trying out the Amish staples like Chicken Pot-Pie or Chicken corn soup.

Amish Buffet in Lancaster PA

It’s no Secret that Lancaster has the best buffet Pennsylvania. Some are more like an adventure than a meal.


Like I said, I love food so I prefer the buffets, I’m like a kid in a candy store, “what to pick, what to pick, oh the struggles!” It’s like a treat. Limiting choices to a menu is not nearly as fun. Menu’s are not healthy they can bring remorse if you pick the wrong thing.

Growing up in Pennsylvania with a German and Mennonite heritage, Amish food clearly reminds me of true home cooking. You might even say I’m a little bias but I’d prefer to look at it as, I’m a bit of an expert.

authentic amish restaurants in Lancaster,PA

Smokehouse BBQ and Brews

Serves: Local cuisine, American, Dutch, Barbecue, Gluten Free Options

Address: 3121 Old Philadelphia Pike, Plain & Fancy Farm, Bird in Hand, PA 17505-9630

Customer Favorites: The Smoke BBQ sauce. Homestyle barbeque platters, including chicken, pork, and sausages

Smokehouse Website

Smokehouse Menu

Claim to Fame: Craft beers, locally made wines and cocktails. Featuring traditional Lancaster County dishes, including the famous “Build-Your-Own-Feast”.

Katies Kitchen Lancaster, PA

Katie’s Kitchen

Opened in 2012

 Closed Sundays and Mondays. Amish owned and operated.

Serves: American, Dutch, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options

Address: 200 Hartman Bridge Road Ronks, PA 17572

Customer Favorites: Homemade Dinner Specials

Katie’s Kitchen Website

Katie’s Kitchen Menu

Claim to Fame: Amish Dinner Catering, Recommended by; Visit Lancaster PA. Voted #2 Restaurant in Ronks by Trip Advisor

authentic amish restaurants in Lancaster,PA

1899 Olde Mill Restaurant

Serves: American, Dutch, Vegetarian Friendly.  Full Service local traditional Lancaster menu dishes and a smorgasbord of daily “All-You-Can-Eat”

Address: 9 Queen Rd Best Western Intercourse, Intercourse, PA 17534-7000

Customer Favorites: Casual and cozy is the style with a small town atmosphere

1899 Olde Mill Website

1899 Olde Mill Menu

Claim to Fame: Historic Mill. Grilled Sticky Buns

Find the RV of Your Dreams... HERE RVT.com...successfully connecting RV Buyers and Sellers for over 15 years.
Authentic Amish Restaurants Lancaster, PA

Good N Plenty Restaurant

Opened in 1969

Serves: Family style all you can eat platters are bought to the table. American, Dutch, Vegetarian Friendly. Offers a daily Specials menu

Address: 150 Eastbrook Road (Route 896) Smoketown (Lancaster County) PA 17576  

Customer Favorites: PA Dutch sampler that includes their world famous chicken, meat loaf, pork and sauerkraut with 2 sides.

Good N Plenty Website

Good N Plenty Menu

Claim to fame: Awards ”Best Local PA Dutch Restaurant”, Top 10 Best“Down Home Dining”. Voted #1 Restaurant in Smoketown by Trip Advisor

Guided Brewery Walking Tour in Lancaster

45-Minute Private Historic Walking Tour in Lititz

authentic amish restaurants in Lancaster,PA

Lititz Family Cupboard

 Serves: American, Dutch, Vegetarian Friendly. Has Buffet and has a large menu to order from as well

Address: 12 W Newport Rd., Lititz, PA 17543

Customer Favorites: Choose from an extensive menu of made-from-scratch desserts at the Cake & Cup Bake Shoppe

Lititz Family Cupboard Website

Lititz Family Cupboard Menu

Claim to Fame: Friday night Seafood

authentic amish restaurants

Hershey Farm Restaurant

 Serves: American & Dutch Cuisine. Smorgasbord includes a made to order Grill

Address: 240 Hartman Bridge Rd, Ronks, PA 17572-9791

Customer Favorites: Unlimited trips to the Soup, Salad, Gourmet Bread & Potato Bar, Grill Station, Hot Food Bars & Dessert Bar

Hershey Farm Website

Hershey Farm Menu

Claim to Fame: Grand Smorgasbord with Traditional PA Dutch favorites and modern flavors on the hot food bars. Seniors receive 15% off Lunch & Dinner prices.

Authentic Amish Restaurants Lancaster, PA

Yoder’s Restaurant and Buffet

Serves: American, Dutch, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options plus Open for Sunday Brunch.

Address: 14 S Tower Road, New Holland, PA 17557-1517

Customer Favorites: Grill station featuring made-to-order omelets, crepes, pancakes, eggs, corn fritters, quiche, bacon, sausage, scrapple

Yoder’s Website

Yoder’s Breakfast Menu

Yoder’s Lunch & Dinner Menu

Claim to Fame: Fresh from our farm to your family. Voted #1 restaurant in New Holland by Trip advisor

Authentic Amish Restaurants Lancaster, PA

Shady Maple Smorgasbord Restaurant

Opened in 1985

Serves Buffet style only with a different menu everyday of the week. Local cuisine, Quick Bites, American, Dutch, Vegetarian Friendly

Address: 129 Toddy Drive East Earl, PA 17519

Customer Favorites: Daily Dinner features, Free birthday meal with 1 paying adult

Shady Maple Website

Shady Maple Menu

Claim to Fame: Discover the experience of dining at Lancaster County’s largest smorgasbord featuring 200 feet of deliciously authentic Pennsylvania Dutch cooking.

Authentic Amish Restaurants Lancaster, PA

Miller’s Smorgasbord

Opened in 1929,

Serves: American, Dutch, Soups, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options

Three Dining options:

  1. Traditional Smorgasbord/Buffet
  2. Soup & Salad Smorgasbord/Buffet
  3. Menu Dining, back by popular demand

2811 Lincoln Hwy E, Ronks, PA 17572-9601

Customer Favorites: chicken & waffles

Miller’s Website

Miller’s Menu

Claim to Fame:  PA Preferred, AAA Recommended, Reader’s Choice and ServSafe Award Winners.

Bird in hand restaurant

Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord

Opened in 1970

Serves: Menu and buffet style. Local cuisine, American, Dutch, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options

Address: 2760 Old Philadelphia Pike
Bird-in-Hand, PA USA 17505

Customer Favorites: Handcrafted sandwiches, crisp salads, soups, smoothies, desserts-all made with high quality ingredients

Bird-in-Hand Website

Bird-in Hand Menu

Claim to Fame: Only the freshest ingredients. In season, produce comes from local Amish and Mennonite farms, and we use meat and poultry from local producers. Some of our most popular traditional Pennsylvania Dutch recipes date back to Grandma Smucker. Voted #1 Restaurant in bird-in-Hand by Trip Advisor

Authentic Amish Restaurants Lancaster, PA

Dienner's Country Restaurant

Opened in 1993

 Serves: Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Brunch. Buffet Style or menu, until 5:00pm, Daily menu favorites. Buffet only after 5:00pm. Serving American, Dutch, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options

Address: 2855 Lincoln Hwy E, Ronks, PA 17572-9607

Customer favorites: Rotisserie Chicken, Buttered Noodles, Beef & Gravy

Dienner’s Website

Dienner’s Menu

Claim to fame: The food is always fresh because they cook in small batches. Voted #1 Restaurant in the Ronks by Trip Advisor

💜 PIN it! 💜

💜 If you found this article to be useful Click on a PIN to save to your Pinterest Travel Board for later 💜

Amish restaurants in Lancaster PA

💜Leave a reply below if you have a favorite authentic Amish restaurant or suggestion that you would like to share💜

Ultimate Guide to the Best of Lancaster, Pennsylvania

US National Parks, America's New Favorite Vacation

The bottle-sized chair for anywhere. Shop Now!

Hello friends, glad you could make it. Imagine if you could completely catapult your travel experience to the next level. That’s what kalistravelguide.com set out to do.

Sign up here Contact Kali for all of my insider tips, reviews, strategies and the best of Travel Deals.

Are you ready? Because this is what following your dreams looks like.   Enjoy!-Kali

Share Buttons


Travel Trends

Lancaster Breweries

Guide to the Tastiest Lancaster Breweries

Guide to the Tastiest Lancaster Breweries If you come to Lancaster, PA, it’s a pity not to enjoy everything the city and its traditions have to offer. And the brewing

Katies Kitchen Lancaster, PA

11 Authentic Amish Restaurants in Lancaster PA

11 Authentic Amish Restaurants in Lancaster PA Everyone knows the Amish always sprinkle a bit of love on their food.Amish Restaurants in Lancaster PA is perfect for people looking for

Smoky mountain waterfalls

Guide to 7 Easy Smoky Mountain Waterfalls

7 Easy Waterfall Trails in the Great Smoky Mountain National Park If you enjoy the scenic outdoors, look no further. Here are 7 Easy Trails With Great Smoky Mountain Waterfalls that

Leave a Comment